Cobble Hill Homes under $2.5 million

Welcome to Cobble Hill, a charming neighborhood nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, NY, where historic charm meets modern living. Known for its picturesque tree-lined streets and beautifully preserved brownstones, Cobble Hill offers a unique blend of old-world elegance and contemporary vibrancy. This hidden gem is a haven for those seeking a tight-knit community atmosphere, yet with easy access to the bustling energy of New York City.

As you stroll through Cobble Hill, you'll discover an array of delightful boutiques, artisanal cafes, and eclectic restaurants that cater to every palate. The neighborhood is also home to several parks, including the serene Cobble Hill Park, perfect for a leisurely afternoon or a family picnic. With its rich history and artistic flair, Cobble Hill has become a sought-after destination for families, young professionals, and anyone looking to enjoy the best of Brooklyn living.

For those considering a move to this enchanting neighborhood, you'll be pleased to know that Cobble Hill offers a variety of homes under $2.5 million. From spacious brownstones with original architectural details to modern condos featuring sleek finishes, there's something for everyone. These homes provide not just a place to live, but a lifestyle that embraces community, culture, and convenience.

Whether you’re looking for a cozy nest or a stylish urban retreat, Cobble Hill is a neighborhood that captures the essence of Brooklyn living. Experience the charm, community, and character that make Cobble Hill one of Brooklyn’s most desirable neighborhoods. Your dream home awaits!

Newest Cobble Hill Homes under $2.5 million

$500,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20117264 MLS

Welcome to 417 Hicks, Residence 1B, set within Cobble Hill Towers, one of Brooklyn’s most distinctive landmarked residential communities. This lovely one bedroom home pairs historic character with clean, modern finishes. The open kitchen features light natural wood cabinetry, sleek countertops and stainless steel appliances, including a gas range, built-in microwave and dishwasher, along with a generous peninsula with counter seating. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the living area, creating a bright, loft-like space with warm hardwood floors and high ceilings. Exposed brick, custom open shelving and built-in storage add character while providing plenty of space for books, art and display. The generously proportioned bedroom comfortably accommodates a king size bed and offers excellent closet storage. Just off the bedroom, the windowed full bath features white tile, hexagonal tile flooring, a glass-enclosed walk-in shower, contemporary vanity and chrome fixtures. The apartment also includes a washer/dryer hookup for added convenience. Dating to the late 19th century, Cobble Hill Towers is a landmarked red-brick enclave of nine buildings bordering Warren, Baltic and Hicks Streets, known for its historic design, wrought-iron details and two beautifully landscaped private gardens exclusive to residents. Building amenities include on-site laundry, bike storage and a live-in superintendent. Pets welcome. Ideally positioned at the crossroads of Cobble Hill and Brooklyn Heights, 417 Hicks Street is moments from the shops, cafés and restaurants of Court and Smith Streets, Cobble Hill Park and the waterfront at Brooklyn Bridge Park. Multiple subway lines provide convenient access throughout Brooklyn and into Manhattan.

417 Hicks St Unit 1B, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

$1,650,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20116663 MLS

Discover a rare combination of expansive living, outdoor space and modern comforts in this sun-drenched, full-floor Cobble Hill condominium. With 1267 sq. ft. of beautifully designed interior space, and approximately 500 sq ft of outdoor space, including a 375 SQUARE FOOT PRIVATE ROOFDECK, this elegant 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence offers both sophistication and warmth. The keyed elevator opens directly into a spacious foyer that leads into a grand, open-concept living/dining area with soaring 10’ ceilings. Entertain to your hearts delight, with a 22’ wide layout, you have plenty of space for all. Three oversized west-facing City Quiet windows provide amazing natural sunlight throughout the day; recessed lighting and gorgeous wide-plank hardwood floors add to its allure. The large chef's kitchen is equipped with plentiful custom wood cabinetry, slate countertops, and stainless steel appliances, including a 30” double oven gas range, a 36” refrigerator, and a dishwasher making it ideal for hosting gatherings. Have dinner parties with family and friends inside, or head upstairs to enjoy unobstructed views on your very own 375 SF rooftop terrace on the rear of the building. The pin-drop quiet primary bedroom comfortably accommodates a king-sized bedroom set and features an en-suite bathroom, walk-in closet, and a charming and serene balcony overlooking backyards and trees. The spacious second bedroom serves as a great kids room, a guest room or a fabulous home office. Enjoy the comforts of central heating and air conditioning, ample storage with multiple closets (2 walk-in’s), and the convenience of an in-unit washer and dryer. This residence is within an intimate, well-managed building of only five units, ensuring peace and tranquility. Recent capital improvements include a brand new elevator system, a new roof as of 2023 and a virtual doorman system. Cobble Hill is a quintessential Brooklyn neighborhood offering the perfect blend of historic charm and modern amenities. Stately brownstones, charming churches, and authentic Italian bakeries dot the landscape, alongside first-class restaurants, coffee shops, and boutiques. Experience local favorites like Lucali, Henry Public, La Vara, Barbalu Brooklyn and The Clover Club. This is your opportunity to enjoy unparalleled living space and outdoor luxury in one of Brooklyn's most sought-after neighborhoods.

473 Hicks St Unit 3, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

$1,775,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20108329 MLS

Welcome to 16 Wyckoff Street, where considered design, townhouse character, and an exceptional Brooklyn lifestyle come together. Perched atop a grand 25-foot-wide townhouse at the crossroads of Cobble Hill and Boerum Hill, this penthouse residence offers the rare combination of beautifully renovated interiors, a roof deck, skyline views, and one of the most walkable addresses in Brooklyn. Gut-renovated to the studs in 2021, the home has been thoughtfully composed to feel both refined and distinctly Brooklyn. An exposed-brick entry introduces warmth and texture before opening into a custom sage-green kitchen finished with quartz countertops, brass hardware, and a premium appliance suite featuring Fisher & Paykel, ILVE, Bosch, and GE. Beyond the kitchen, framed views of the Downtown Brooklyn skyline provide an ever-changing backdrop. The living and dining room is bright, inviting, and beautifully proportioned, with three picturesque windows overlooking tree-lined Wyckoff Street. Custom built-in bookshelves add architectural character, while generous proportions allow for a true dining area-equally suited to intimate dinners and lively evenings with friends. Two bedrooms and two full baths offer both privacy and flexibility. The oversized primary suite is a serene retreat with a custom closet and ensuite bath featuring a deep soaking tub, Toto washlet, and generous vanity. The second bedroom features a custom Murphy bed with integrated storage, allowing it to transition effortlessly between bedroom, guest suite, and home office. A second full bath with soaking tub and Toto washlet sits beside a custom laundry closet with Samsung washer and dryer. Modern comforts are seamlessly integrated throughout, including a Mitsubishi mini-split system and Pella wood-trim windows installed in 2023. Above it all is the home's defining feature: the finished portion-roof deck reserved exclusively for this residence. Morning coffee, dinner al fresco, sunset cocktails- the space becomes a true outdoor living room, with sweeping views across Brooklyn and toward the Manhattan skyline. Unused FAR may also present the opportunity to create a penthouse duplex, subject to co-op board and applicable regulatory approvals. The intimate three-unit co-op is self-managed by long-term owners and offers exceptionally low carrying costs, no building mortgage, dedicated basement storage, and the benefit of recent building improvements. This is Brooklyn living at its most effortless. Step outside and nearly everything is within a few blocks: morning coffee, destination dining, independent boutiques, groceries, cocktails, parks, cinema, and everyday essentials. Trader Joe’s, Court Street Bagels, Maman, Books Are Magic, Cobble Hill Cinemas, La Vara, Saint Julivert, June Wine Bar, and the shops and restaurants of Court, Smith, and Atlantic are all part of the neighborhood rhythm. Brooklyn Bridge Park and the waterfront are close by, while neighboring Carroll Gardens, Boerum Hill, and Brooklyn Heights expand the possibilities even further. The Bergen Street F/G is just a block away, with additional subway lines nearby for easy access throughout the city. Cobble Hill has long been prized for its historic streets, village-like intimacy, and remarkable convenience. At 16 Wyckoff Street #4, that coveted lifestyle begins at your front door. **A beautifully realized home. A rooftop above Brooklyn. And a neighborhood you may never want to leave.**

16 Wyckoff St Unit 4, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

$695,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20113624 MLS

Welcome to the sweetest home to hit the fall market, 202 Baltic St, unit 4. Full of charm and glowing light, this home embodies calm. Located in the heart of Cobble Hill, you’ll never want to (or have to) go far. Whether looking for a first home, or a home to lay down roots, you’ve just found the one that you didn’t even know that you needed. Exhale the moment you arrive. 202 Baltic St is a charming 1 bd coop apartment located in central Cobble Hill. Perched above a gorgeous tree lined street, you are sure to appreciate the light and views all day long. Enjoy 3 exposures (north, east, and west). The living room faces north and west with light wrapping around the room. Cozy up by the home’s wood burning fireplace or sit in the corner wrapped in natural light, to enjoy a book or conversation. The galley kitchen has a new stainless Verona stove, a Summit fridge, and matching hood that vents out. There’s open shelving lining the walls. The bedroom is large, fitting any sized bed of your choice and also a dresser and side table. The room is lined with south garden facing windows. A newly renovated bathroom, is complete with a soaking tub and terrazzo tiled floors. There are hardwood floors throughout the home. Low carrying costs at just $769 per month. There’s storage that comes with the unit and laundry is available in the building, at no additional cost for residents. Quintessential Brownstone Brooklyn living, with everything you need just blocks away. This delightful home puts you blocks from acclaimed dining at La Vara, Al Badawi, and Lillo Cucina. Trader Joe's covers your grocery run, while specialty shops like Staubitz, Sahadi's, and One Girl Cookies round out the neighborhood's charm. Tree-lined streets, timeless charm, unbeatable access—202 Baltic Street has it all.

202 Baltic St Unit 4, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

$885,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20113075 MLS

Let the sun shine in! This fabulous Cobble Hill two-bedroom apartment with south-facing views is the perfect place to call home. The apartment features a modern open-plan kitchen with a large Jenn-Air oven, Maytag refrigerator, and Bosch dishwasher and microwave, all flowing seamlessly into the spacious, light-filled dining and living area. The best perk of top-floor living is proximity to the incredible common roof deck. With southwest views, you’ll have a front row seat to unforgettable sunsets. This home offers two bedrooms with ample closet space, including a custom-built closet in the primary bedroom. The second bedroom is perfect for a nursery and can also easily serve as a guest room or home office. The modern bathroom features a west-facing window that fills the space with beautiful natural light, and the gallery-style entrance hallway is ideal for showcasing artwork and welcoming guests. Additional conveniences include an in-unit stackable washer and dryer and a transferable storage locker for $20 per month. Building amenities include a beautifully landscaped common rooftop deck with flowers, plants, and a vegetable garden (residents can participate in gardening if interested), reading, exercising or yoga, and hosting friends for drinks or dinner. This pet-friendly building also offers bike storage, stroller and scooter storage, card-operated laundry, and a video intercom system. One block from Trader Joe’s and surrounded by great restaurants such as La Vara, Colonie, Rucola, and Ki Sushi, along with bars, boutiques, and gyms (including Equinox, Bar Method, Blink, F45, and SoulCycle). The apartment is also conveniently located near Brooklyn Bridge Park, Barclays Center, the LIRR at Atlantic Terminal, and multiple subway lines (F, G, A, C, 2, 3, 4, 5, and R), all just minutes away.

251 Pacific St Unit 22, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

$599,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20104594 MLS

Bring Your Architect: Blank Canvas Opportunity in Prime Cobble Hill Located on a classic, tree-lined street in the heart of Cobble Hill, Unit 1 at 177 Amity Street offers a rare opportunity to design a bespoke home from the ground up. Requiring a full gut renovation, this 1-bedroom space features high ceilings, southern exposures and a foundation for a custom build-out. The Opportunity: Complete Customization: Full gut renovation required—bring your architect, contractor, and vision to create a space tailored entirely to your lifestyle. Classic Bones: Soaring ceilings and sunny southern exposure fill the apartment with excellent natural light. Unbeatable Value: A chance to enter one of Brooklyn’s most sought-after neighborhoods with limited inventory at an accessible price point. The Neighborhood: You couldn't dream up a better Cobble Hill location. You are steps away from picturesque Cobble Hill Park, the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, and Brooklyn Bridge Park. Enjoy world-class dining, boutique shopping, and local favorites right along Court and Smith Streets—including Trader Joe’s, Sahadi’s, Fish Tales, Bien Cuit, and more. Excellent transit access puts nearly every major subway line within easy reach. The Building: 177 Amity Street is a charming, well-maintained 4-story, 15-unit boutique co-op with on-site laundry and storage in the basement. Policies: Pet-friendly (upon board approval). Please note: Pieds-à-terre are not permitted. Cash purchase required.

177 Amity St Unit 1, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc. All rights reserved.