Carroll Gardens Homes under $2.5 million

Carroll Gardens Homes under $2.5 million

Welcome to Carroll Gardens, a charming neighborhood nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, New York. Known for its tree-lined streets, historic brownstones, and vibrant community spirit, Carroll Gardens offers a unique blend of classic Brooklyn charm and modern living. With its rich Italian heritage, you’ll find delightful cafes, artisanal bakeries, and family-owned restaurants that serve up some of the best cuisine in the borough. Stroll through the neighborhood and you’ll discover lush green spaces like Carroll Park, perfect for a leisurely afternoon or a playful day with the kids.

The real estate market in Carroll Gardens is as diverse as its residents, with homes available under $2.5 million that cater to a variety of tastes and lifestyles. Whether you’re looking for a beautifully renovated brownstone with original architectural details or a modern condo with all the latest amenities, this neighborhood has something to offer everyone. With its strong sense of community and proximity to Manhattan, Carroll Gardens is an ideal choice for families, young professionals, and anyone looking to experience the best of Brooklyn living.

Residents enjoy easy access to public transportation, making it a breeze to commute into the city or explore the vibrant surrounding neighborhoods. The local schools, parks, and community events foster a welcoming atmosphere that truly makes Carroll Gardens feel like home. Discover the magic of this beloved Brooklyn enclave and find your perfect home in Carroll Gardens today!

Newest Carroll Gardens Homes under $2.5 million

188 Degraw St Unit 3, Brooklyn
$1,695,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20121534 MLS
Welcome to 188 Degraw Street, Unit 3, a light-filled, pet friendly home at the crossroads of Carroll Gardens and Cobble Hill. Set atop an intimate three-unit co-op, this inviting residence blends historic Brooklyn character with thoughtful modern updates, offering a wonderful combination of comfort, charm, and functionality. The newly renovated chef’s kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring a generous center island, stainless steel appliances, a dishwasher, and a dedicated wine fridge. Host a crowd around the island or settle in for a cozy dinner beside the wood-burning fireplace, which brings warmth and character to the living space. Oversized windows and sliding glass doors fill the home with an abundance of natural light, beautifully complementing the rich hardwood floors and creating a bright, airy atmosphere throughout. Step onto your private front terrace for morning coffee, outdoor dining, or an evening breeze above the treetops, all while enjoying peaceful views overlooking the charming, tree-lined Cheever Place. The primary suite offers a peaceful retreat, complete with an updated, spa-inspired en-suite bath. A well-proportioned second bedroom features a custom closet, providing flexibility for guests, a home office, or additional living space. The tastefully renovated hallway bathroom features a deep soaking tub, perfect for unwinding at the end of the day. An in-unit washer and dryer and dedicated attic storage add everyday convenience, rounding out this thoughtfully updated Brooklyn home. Just beyond your door, discover the charming boutiques, neighborhood favorites, and vibrant dining scene that make Carroll Gardens and Cobble Hill two of Brooklyn’s most sought-after neighborhoods. With tree-lined streets and an abundance of local shops, cafés, and restaurants just moments away, 188 Degraw Street offers the perfect balance of neighborhood charm and city convenience.

188 Degraw St Unit 3, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

118 Union St Unit 6B, Brooklyn
$995,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20121139 MLS ⋅ Fifth Columbia Terr BLDG.
At long last, the ever-elusive true two bedroom Brownstone Brooklyn condo under $1MM has emerged! Perfectly perched at the crossroads of Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens, and Red Hook, this beautifully renovated, sun-soaked home set within the highly sought after Columbia Street Waterfront District checks all the boxes, and then some.Enter residence 6B after a short one flight walkup to find a bright, thoughtfully designed space highlighted by its sprawling living/dining room. With ample room in which to dine and entertain, the space flows seamlessly into the massive, fully renovated open chef's kitchen. Featuring Pietra Cardosa quartzite countertops, fresh stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, a Summit 48-bottle dual-zone wine refrigerator and a butcher block-topped floating breakfast bar, this special space will leave you wanting for nothing.Down the hall neatly tucked away from the living spaces, lie two symmetrical, spacious bedrooms. The oversized primary bedroom easily accommodates a king-sized bed and plenty of furniture - not to mention its perfect walk-in closet - while the well-proportioned second bedroom can comfortably function as both a bedroom and office space in one. Just outside of the bedrooms, the renovated bathroom is finished with a clean, modern aesthetic and a full tub.Residence 6B is move-in ready. It comes replete with an in-unit washer/dryer, sparkling hardwood floors, Nest thermostat, smart-home enabled switches, ceiling fans, and generous closet space, while the monthlies are incredibly low. The apartment is part of a special condominium community known as Columbia Street Garden Mews. In addition to its low monthlies, the property features professional management, bike storage and a massive shared courtyard/garden for all residents to enjoy.118 Union Street is zoned for PS 29. It leaves you moments from copious amounts of dining and shopping options, the tree-lined streets of Cobble Hill/Carroll Gardens, coupled with endless activities along the waterfront in Red Hook and Brooklyn Bridge Park. Quick commutes are made possible by the nearby ferry stop, in addition to easy access to the F, G, 2, 3, 4, 5 subway lines.With exceptionally low monthly carrying costs, the flexibility of a condo, a pet-friendly building and Fios availability, this is a truly turnkey home in one of the Brooklyn's most charming, exciting and increasingly sought-after pockets. Welcome home.

118 Union St Unit 6B, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

62 4th Pl Unit 2, Brooklyn
$2,295,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20118948 MLS
A boutique collection of four condominium residences set within a historic 25-foot-wide Carroll Gardens townhouse. Every home features private outdoor space, exceptional craftsmanship, and a level of finish that honors the neighborhood’s architectural legacy while delivering the ease of modern living. Unit Two offers a thoughtfully configured single-floor layout with a rear-facing terrace off the main living area. The primary bedroom suite features a walk-in closet and a gracious bedroom proportion rarely found in new construction at this scale. Clean, livable, and beautifully finished throughout. 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | 1202SF • Terrace: 17'11" x 5'4" • 22 SF Deeded Storage INTERIORS • Wide-plank, solid white oak flooring • In-Unit LG stacked washer and externally vented dryer • Alutech triple-glazed casement windows for superior sound attenuation and energy efficiency • Variable refrigerant flow (VRF) split-type heat pump system providing individual heating and cooling • Energy Recovery Ventilator providing continuously filtered, tempered fresh air • Airphone GT Series video intercom system • Common roof deck KITCHENS • Bellagio quartzite countertops and backsplash • Bertazzoni induction ranges • Fully integrated Liebherr refrigerators • Fully integrated Bosch Dishwashers • Zephyr externally vented exhaust fans • Newport Brass and Kohler Fixture BATHROOMS • Toto and Kohler fixtures • Duravit Architect soaking tub • Honed Carrara Marble floors and Cosmos Ice Porcelain Spanish wall tile in secondary baths • Marble Bianco de Oro Shower wall tile and Anciano Grigio Marble flooring in Primary Baths Note images are digital representations.

62 4th Pl Unit 2, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Corcoran Group.

350 De Graw St Unit 4, Brooklyn
$1,495,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20120405 MLS
Welcome to 350 Degraw Street, a boutique 4 unit condominium nestled in the heart of Brooklyn's vibrant and stylish Carroll Gardens.Penthouse Residence No. 4 is a sophisticated two-bedroom, one-bathroom home offering exceptional indoor-outdoor living, with a private entry vestibule, two private outdoor spaces, and access to a shared rooftop deck with sweeping Manhattan and Brooklyn skyline views.The expansive 375-square-foot private terrace, accessed directly from the living room and conveniently connected to the kitchen, creates an ideal setting for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply enjoying the city skyline. A second 75-square-foot balcony spans both south-facing bedrooms, bringing abundant natural light and fresh air into the home.The contemporary kitchen is thoughtfully appointed with premium stainless-steel appliances, including a vented Wolf range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, and Miele dishwasher, complemented by a General Electric microwave. The spacious spa-like bathroom features a glass-enclosed shower, Kohler soaking tub, Toto toilet, rain showerheads, and elegant Italian Carrara and Dolomite marble tilework.Additional features include multi-zoned central heating and air conditioning, an in-home laundry room, wide-plank oak flooring, recessed lighting, and custom closet inserts designed to maximize storage and make move-in effortless.Located in the heart of Carroll Gardens, 350 Degraw Street places you just moments from the neighborhood's exceptional shopping, dining, and café scene along Smith and Court Streets. Carroll Park, with its playground and green space, is nearby, while a wonderful selection of boutiques, grocers, restaurants, and cafés are all within easy reach.Transportation is convenient with the F train on Smith Street just a short distance away.Crowning this exceptional residence is the shared residents' rooftop deck, offering spectacular panoramic views across the Manhattan and Brooklyn skylines-a perfect place to unwind, entertain, and take in the best of Brooklyn living.This condominium has an incredible advantage of the monthly costs being under $ 900, including both taxes and common charge.

350 De Graw St Unit 4, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

1 Tiffany Pl Unit 4H, Brooklyn
$1,595,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20116140 MLS
Massive 2-Bed/2-Bath Apartment with Incredible City and Water Views and Private Deeded Parking! Experience luxury living in this spacious 1,245 sq. ft. apartment, boasting breathtaking views, modern amenities, and private deeded parking right in the heart of the Columbia Waterfront District. This unit features: Stunning Views: City skyline, Statue of Liberty, and waterfront vistas. Elegant Details: Decorative fireplace and custom-built media cabinetry. Brand-New Kitchen: Modern fixtures, high-end appliances, kitchen bar, and dedicated dining area. Convenience & Comfort: In-unit washer/dryer, air conditioning, and ample storage. Bright & Airy: Large double-pane windows and gleaming hardwood floors. Housed in a historic Louis Comfort Tiffany warehouse converted into a full-service, five-story condominium, this building offers: 24-hour attended lobby with doorman Two elevators and a live-in superintendent Fitness center and children's playroom Bike storage and common courtyard Complimentary shuttle to Borough Hall subway, serving the 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, F, and R trains during commuting hours Nestled on one of Brooklyn's last remaining tree-lined cobblestone streets, this apartment offers a prime location in the thriving Columbia Waterfront District. Enjoy easy access to: Brooklyn Bridge Park and the Brooklyn Waterfront Greenway Recreational facilities at Van Voorhees Park, including tennis and basketball courts and a baseball field Renowned restaurants, unique shops, art galleries, cafés, and community gardens Zoned for P.S. 29, one of the area's most highly regarded schools, this is the perfect home for those seeking luxury, history, and a vibrant community. Please note: There are currently two assessments in place: a $135.15 Elevator Modernization Assessment, which ends May 1, 2029, and a $196.60 ongoing Capital Provision Assessment. Please note: Photos are virtually staged

1 Tiffany Pl Unit 4H, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Corcoran Group.

537 Clinton St Unit 3B, Brooklyn
$849,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20116444 MLS
Expertly gut-renovated and comprehensively reimagined by a premier developer and acclaimed interior designer, this one-of-a-kind one-bedroom home was completely reconfigured to maximize space, functionality, and flow. The original layout was transformed, with the kitchen, living area, and bedroom relocated to create an exceptionally considered home where custom craftsmanship and intelligent design inform every inch. Nearly every element of the home has been considered and custom-built, with extensive bespoke millwork creating a warm, cohesive interior while incorporating an extraordinary amount of storage and functionality. Natural wood, cane detailing, richly veined stone, and warm brass accents establish a refined material palette throughout. At the entry, custom millwork incorporates a built-in bench, concealed shoe storage, and aged-brass hooks, creating a dedicated and highly functional drop zone. The living room is wrapped in custom millwork incorporating bookcases, open shelving, a wine rack, and a cleverly concealed queen-size Murphy bed with integrated sofa, allowing the space to transition seamlessly for overnight guests. A custom Super White marble dining banquette upholstered in buffalo leather provides additional storage beneath the seating, while the bespoke dining table is topped in the same stone used in the kitchen, visually connecting the two spaces. The beautifully executed kitchen pairs custom cabinetry with cane detailing and Super White marble countertops and backsplash. High-end appliances include an integrated Bosch refrigerator, Miele wall oven and fully integrated Miele dishwasher, along with an integrated PITT three-burner gas cooktop. In the bedroom, the home's custom approach continues with an integrated Queen-size bed and headboard, custom built-in closets, a built-in desk/vanity, open shelving, and cane detailing. Articulating bedside sconces are incorporated directly into the millwork. The result is a serene sleeping space with substantial storage and functionality built into every detail. The bathroom is equally considered, featuring radiant heated floors, a custom Calacatta Viole marble vanity and sink, burnished-brass fixtures, a frameless glass shower, built-in shower niche, and a wall-mounted Duravit toilet with SensoWash. Additional features include MAFI wood flooring throughout, Mitsubishi multi-zone heating and cooling, custom window millwork, integrated LED lighting, Lutron lighting controls, an August smart lock, Aiphone video intercom and a concealed in-unit Bosch stacked washer and dryer. The result is a rare one-bedroom that feels more like a bespoke residence than a conventional apartment. Beautifully designed, exceptionally efficient, and unlike anything else on the market. Set on a picturesque, tree-lined block in the heart of Carroll Gardens, 537 Clinton Street is part of an intimate collection of three adjoining four-story co-ops, with just two residences per floor. This pet-friendly building offers dedicated basement storage and a warm, neighborly feel, moments from Carroll Park, the shops and restaurants of Smith and Court Streets, and the Carroll Street F/G trains. Please note some of the photos are virtually staged.

537 Clinton St Unit 3B, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Corcoran Group.

505 Court St Unit 5H, Brooklyn
$1,700,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20098414 MLS ⋅ Court Street Lofts BLDG.
Apt 5H at The Court St Lofts is an expansive 1,142-square-foot two-bedroom, two-bath home that captures the light and space character of an authentic NY loft, while seamlessly blending elevated modern finishes and comforts. Defined by exposed factory columns-a signature of the building-the home opens into a sprawling living and dining area with soaring 12-foot ceilings and dramatic, oversized industrial windows that span the entire wall. A soft even light fills the space, while offering sweeping views of Lower Manhattan and Downtown Brooklyn.The open chef's kitchen is beautifully appointed with natural quartzite countertops and a premium suite of appliances, including a Wolf range, Bosch dishwasher, Viking refrigerator, and a dedicated wine fridge. Wide-plank oak floors add warmth and run throughout the entire apartment. An enormous coat closet down the hall adds functionality.The oversized primary bedroom offers exceptional scale and flexibility, complete with custom millwork closets and a thoughtfully designed nook-perfect for a home office or Peloton setup. The renovated primary bathroom feature calacata gold marble tile, cove lighting, a custom vanity and refined nickel fixtures for a spa-like experience.The generously proportioned second bedroom is equally impressive, featuring custom closet systems. The second bathroom was also recently renovated, in 2021, and finished in elegant marble tile, including a striking chevron pattern tile along the walls. Storage is a standout feature of the home, with extensive custom closets and cleverly integrated hidden storage throughout.A rare offering that combines volume, light, craftsmanship, and iconic loft details, this residence delivers sophisticated Brooklyn living at its finest.The Court Street Lofts is a pet friendly, professionally managed, full-service condo that offers a 24-hour doorman, a gorgeous, spacious courtyard including BBQs, picnic tables, and Adirondack Chairs, as well as a recently renovated fitness center and hallways. The building has bike storage and individual storage units for a fee. Located in an ideal part of Carroll Gardens, find yourself just steps away from the F/G train, Citi Bike and the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel. Neighborhood favorites include Lucali's, Court Street Grocers, Frankie's 457 Spuntino, Baby Luc's, F&F Pizzeria, Other Half Brewery as well as Whole Foods. Currently zoned for P.S. 58 elementary school. There is an ongoing assessment for $350/month May 2032.Call us today for your private viewing! This gem won't last long! Seller/owner

505 Court St Unit 5H, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

100 Congress St Unit 406, Brooklyn
$1,995,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ RLS20115282 MLS
This streamlined, contemporary, and beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo is located precisely where Cobble Hill meets the Columbia Street Waterfront, offering an expansive and light-filled layout elevated by a suite of high-end, thoughtful upgrades.From the moment you enter, oversized windows flood the entire residence with an abundance of natural light, framing a picturesque vista that captures both the iconic Manhattan skyline and a lush canopy of treetops. No detail was overlooked in the refinement of this home, which boasts elegant wide white oak flooring, custom woodwork, and clean-lined HVAC cabinetry that seamlessly blends into the architecture. The heart of the home is a striking, open-concept living and dining space that pairs perfectly with a custom-designed walnut kitchen, fully integrated with premium appliances including a SubZero refrigerator and Miele cooktop, oven, and dishwasher, alongside a wealth of seamless built-in storage. While the primary living area is spacious, warm, and exceptionally inviting, the dining area was meticulously constructed to carve out a charming, full-sized dining nook accompanied by ample hidden closet storage. Designed for sophisticated, private relaxation, the generous primary bedroom is tucked away on its own side of the residence, featuring a large walk-in closet and an en-suite full bathroom complete with Jacuzzi bathtub. The additional two bedrooms are equally airy and bright, featuring tailored, built-out closets that maximize every inch of space. Additional conveniences include a second white-tiled bathroom with soaking tub, zoned heating and air conditioning units, and an in-unit Bosch washer and dryer .Set within 100 Congress-one of Brooklyn's most beloved and scenic waterfront enclaves currently zoned for PS 29-residents enjoy unparalleled access to an incredible lifestyle. You are directly across the street from the Van Voorhees playground and tennis courts, and just moments from the world-class Brooklyn Bridge Park, which offers stunning waterfront promenades, playgrounds, athletic fields, and picnic lawns. The neighborhood's celebrated culinary and shopping scene is right at your doorstep, with grocery staples like Trader Joe's and Union Market close by, and local favorites including Lucali, Popina, Long Island Bar, Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain, Sahadi's, and the boutique shops along Smith Street, Court Street, and Atlantic Avenue just a short stroll away. The condo's robust amenity package includes a virtual doorman, package room, live-in super, a comfortable residents' lounge, children's playroom, fitness center, common laundry room with commercial-size washers and dryers, and two common outdoor spaces, including a striking roof deck with panoramic views of the Manhattan skyline. Getting around is easy, with convenient access to the 2, 3, 4, 5, F, G, A, C, and R subway lines, plus the Pier 6 NYC Ferry offering direct service to Lower Manhattan and beyond.

100 Congress St Unit 406, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

450 Clinton St Unit 4D, Brooklyn
$765,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ RLS20105775 MLS
Welcome to 450 Clinton Street #4D, a spacious one-bedroom located in the historic Old Westminster Church Co-op in the heart of Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn—one of NYC’s most charming and sought-after neighborhoods. This thoughtfully designed home features a unique multi-level layout, offering a natural separation between living and sleeping areas for enhanced privacy and flow. The king-sized bedroom is generously proportioned, complete with a large en-suite closet and room for additional furnishings. The open-concept living and dining area is ideal for both everyday living and entertaining, with abundant natural light filling the space throughout the day. 450 Clinton Street is a well-maintained elevator co-op offering residents a full suite of conveniences, including on-site laundry, a bike room, voice intercom, and a live-in superintendent. A standout feature of the building is its beautifully landscaped shared courtyard, as well as access to a rare, expansive private garden stretching along 1st Place—complete with mature trees, lush greenery, and seating areas for relaxing or dining outdoors. Originally constructed in the 19th century and later converted into residences, the building retains its historic charm while offering modern comforts—making it one of the most distinctive rental opportunities in Carroll Gardens. The location places you moments from some of the best restaurants, cafes, and neighborhood staples in Brooklyn. Enjoy iconic dining at Frankies 457 Spuntino, widely regarded as one of Brooklyn’s essential Italian restaurants , or experience one of NYC’s most famous pizza destinations at Lucali, known for its cult following and long-standing reputation as one of the city’s top pizzerias . Additional neighborhood favorites include F&F Pizzeria, Cafe Spaghetti, Court Street Grocers, and East One Coffee Roasters—all contributing to Carroll Gardens’ reputation as a premier dining destination . For coffee and casual mornings, nearby cafés like Black Gold and East One Coffee Roasters are local staples. Commuting is effortless with the New York City Subway F and G lines at Carroll Street just two blocks away, providing quick and convenient access to Manhattan and beyond. Please note: cats are welcome, and dogs are permitted subject to board approval.

450 Clinton St Unit 4D, Brooklyn

Listing courtesy of Compass.

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc. All rights reserved.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!